WATCH: Jay Leno's Bummed Andy Cohen Wouldn't Shag Him

By: Brandon Voss

"Shag, Marry, Kill" is all fun and games until someone unshaggable gets his feelings hurt.

A recent guest on The Tonight Show, Bravo's Andy Cohen was totally put on the spot when Jay Leno, who apparently knows everything, called Andy out for his rather unflattering response to "Shag, Marry, Kill" the previous day on a local Chicago chat show.

Andy had been forced to choose between late-night hosts Jay Leno, Dave Letterman, and Jimmy Kimmel. “I’m on Leno tomorrow night, so I’d hate to kill him," Andy had said. "That would be bad. I don’t want to shag him.” Cue Leno mock-pouting and guest LL Cool J being awkward about the whole situation. 

“Do you want me to want to shag you?” Andy asked. “It would be nice to know I was wanted,” replied Leno, who later gloated over the fact that he "nailed his ass."

Check out the clip below.

And while we're on the subject... between Jay Leno, Dave Letterman, and Jimmy Kimmel, whom would you shag, marry, or kill?

Tags: TV